04 February 2009

Five years of Facebook. How will it last five more? | Media | guardian.co.uk

Five years of Facebook. How will it last five more? | Media | guardian.co.uk:
Jemima Kiss writes in the Guardian:
"Facebook has many challenges: the battle against social networking fatigue, information overload, the migration of influential early adopters to more specialist networks like Twitter and the intensifying scrutiny of its plans to make money."

Technology is all about change, but will change come due to "networking fatigue"? Bobbie Johnson gives some details about what this might be also in the Guardian Technology Blog:
Listen. I have blog. I use Twitter. I idly flick through lists of people I'd forgotten I ever knew on Facebook. I've even got a MySpace page, although I don't like to talk about it. They are great ways of connecting people, and they're very exciting when you start using them, because they allow virtual contact in ways that are analogous to - if not the same as - real life. You know, communicate with people. That old thing.

Perhaps what we all need is a lesson in setting boundaries on social networking sites, like this one from Nick O'Neill from allfacebook.com: 10 Privacy Settings Every Facebook user should know

25 January 2009

Is the writing on the wall for penmanship? - The Boston Globe

Is the writing on the wall for penmanship? - The Boston Globe:
"'My first reaction was horror,' Florey said in an interview at her home, 'then I thought, 'Why would anyone use handwriting in today's world?' I write my books on the computer. I discovered two schools of thought: One is that it wouldn't matter if nobody learned handwriting because we all have computers, and the other is that this is an interesting, historic, valuable, and beautiful skill that has been around for thousands of years, and we are just tossing it out.'"

This is Kitty Burns Florey talking about her book Script and Scribble: The Rise and Fall of Handwriting. But, the second argument—the argument for the value of handwriting—just is not that convincing. It is like arguing that electric lights have spoiled our ability to appreciate the beauty of candles or that recorded music has caused us to lose our appreciation of the concert hall. It may be quite true, but one can imagine someone saying, "Ah, yes, I wish I did have the time or the opportunity to go to a concert and be able to hear Angela Hewitt play Bach, but not living in London or New York, the CD is the best I can do—in fact, it is amazing that I can have access to this music whenever I want," &c.
The better argument is for the necessity of handwriting. But, perhaps nobody actually believes this argument anymore. I began this blog with a quotation from Orwell on this subject. In the society depicted in Nineteen Eighty-four handwriting is suppressed by the government, and Winston Smith's discovery of it is a turning point:
Actually he was not used to writing by hand. Apart from very short notes, it was usual to dictate everything into the speak-write which was of course impossible for his present purpose.

George Orwell Nineteen Eighty-four Part I

Winston Smith wants to set down his thoughts, "the interminable restless monologue that had been running inside his head, literally for years." But, confronted with the blank paper, his first reaction is an inability to write anything, and second, a stream of "rubbish" written in a rush "in sheer panic." However, the act of writing this incoherent fragment changes something in his mind.
The curious thing was that while he was doing so a totally different memory had clarified itself in his mind, to the point where he almost felt equal to writing it down.

I suspect that this is what many people besides Orwell felt about writing. Writing was an essential part of the job of thinking. And for Orwell, something that an oral medium like his imagined "speakwrite" could not duplicate. Is it the same with the computer? Perhaps. I am one of those people who write on the computer all the time, and yet remain somehow unconvinced that is as good for the process of thinking as handwriting. Typing on the computer is more convenient. It is necessary and unavoidable for my work, but it is detached from the mind in some hard-to-define way.

20 January 2009

Joho the Blog

Joho the Blog:
"While teenagers primarily leverage social network sites to engage in common practices, the properties of these sites configured their practices and teens were forced to contend with the resultant dynamics. Often, in doing so, they reworked the technology for their purposes. As teenagers learned to navigate social network sites, they developed potent strategies for managing the complexities of and social awkwardness incurred by these sites. Their strategies reveal how new forms of social media are incorporated into everyday life, complicating some practices and reinforcing others. New technologies reshape public life, but teens’ engagement also reconfigures the technology itself."

from the abstract to danah boyd's thesis on Social networks.

10 January 2009

The Conversation Prism


As a communications or service professional, you'll find yourself at the center of the prism - whether you're observing, listening or participating.

Interesting. Some leaves seem more crowded than others.

Milky Way Transit Authority

Milky Way Transit Authority: "Urban transit maps are wonderful tools: they are guides to"

Stuck near Sol at the moment, and need a bus ticket. But, at least with a map I know where I am. But, where to go next?

03 January 2009

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk:
"Cloud computing – where IT power is delivered over the internet as you need it, rather than drawn from a desktop computer – has gained currency in recent years. Large internet and technology companies including Google, Microsoft and Amazon are pushing forward their plans to deliver information and software over the net.
But Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and creator of the computer operating system GNU, said that cloud computing was simply a trap aimed at forcing more people to buy into locked, proprietary systems that would cost them more and more over time.
'It's stupidity. It's worse than stupidity: it's a marketing hype campaign,' he told The Guardian.
'Somebody is saying this is inevitable – and whenever you hear somebody saying that, it's very likely to be a set of businesses campaigning to make it true.'"

I read this a while ago, and it has kept coming back to my mind as I have been reading about other things like the Google deal with the publishers, and realizing that freedom of information is not really on their minds at all. I think Stallman is right, and having spent an afternoon this holiday installing Ubuntu on an old computer, I feel it is important not to give into the cloud hype.

30 November 2008

You’re Leaving a Digital Trail. What About Privacy? - NYTimes.com

You’re Leaving a Digital Trail. What About Privacy? - NYTimes.com:

People and organizations, he said, are increasingly choosing to interact with one another through digital means that record traces of those interactions. “This allows scientists to study those interactions in ways that five years ago we never would have thought we could do,” he said.

ONCE based on networked personal computers, collective intelligence systems are increasingly being created to leverage wireless networks of digital sensors and smartphones. In one application, groups of scientists and political and environmental activists are developing “participatory sensing” networks.


This type of work with this interconnected network of cell phones, computer networks, and GPS networks creates a new discipline that Dr. Pentland calls "reality mining" -- in reality an extension of data mining tapping into public data.

Issues of privacy and control of one's personal data, and big-brother type surveillance become important, issues which Steve Steinberg articulates in his .CSV blog in April 08

This emerging area doesn’t have a catchy moniker yet, but you can think of it as an amalgamation of crowd theory, human terrain mapping, and social simulation. It is the science of groups; it is a new kind of quantitative political science.

The tools and theories needed to analyze social interactions are just now reaching the level of sophistication — in accuracy, in robustness – necessary to leave the lab and enter commercial duty. We are in a period analogous to the early 1970s, when developments like the Capital Asset Pricing Model and the Black-Scholes equation transformed finance, changing it from an art to a science, and opening enormous new markets in the process. Now, new equations describing “crowd dynamics” are about to change our lives. And not always for the better. This is one of the most significant technology trends I have seen in years; it may also be one of the most pernicious. (.CSV)

28 November 2008

Search Engine | CBC Radio | Is Canada becoming a digital ghetto?

Search Engine | CBC Radio | Is Canada becoming a digital ghetto?:

1. Last week the CRTC sided with Bell against a group of small Internet Service Providers who want to offer their customers unthrottled connections where what they download is their own business and not subject to interference.

2. In last week’s throne speech the Conservative government renewed their intention to “modernize” Canadian copyright law. Their effort to do so last session was Bill C-61, a woefully unbalanced and retrograde piece of legislation that led to the greatest citizen backlash to any proposed bill in recent memory. Yet there has been no indication from new Industry Minister Tony Clement that a much-needed public consultation will take place. The best he has offered is the possibility of a “slightly different” version of the bill.


So much for net neutrality as far as Canada is concerned...

27 November 2008

Beloit College Mindset List

Beloit College Mindset List:
Number 31 on the Mindset list for the class of 2012
These students,

have never been able to color a tree using a raw umber Crayola.

It has been that many years, and I still feel peeved that they would eliminate raw umber.

19 November 2008

70 Signs of Intelligent Life at YouTube | Open Culture

70 Signs of Intelligent Life at YouTube | Open Culture
Perhaps it is because "YouTube unfortunately makes these collections difficult to find" but it is only recently that I have stumbled across some amazing content on YouTube, for example, just the other day I found some interviews with J. G. Ballard. I have also enjoyed some of the @GoogleTalks, listed on the oculture page.

12 November 2008

William Gibson Interview « Void Manufacturing

William Gibson Interview « Void Manufacturing:

UG: In Spook Country, the net is introduced in a quite specific way; it is somehow turned inside out and projected into real space. You have invented a new art form for that purpose called locative art. For example, you describe a virtual monument on the site of River Phoenix’s death. Why did you choose to write on GPS?

WG: I wanted a way to visualise the extent to which something has changed since I started writing about information technology. When I coined the word cyberspace, cyberspace was there, and everything else was here. That has reversed itself over the course of my writing. I literally think that cyberspace is now here, and a complete lack of connectivity is now there. If we could see the wireless exchanges of digital information taking place around us, we would be living in a much busier visual landscape. Most of what we do as a society we now either primarily do digitally, in what we used to call cyberspace, or we simultaneously do digitally and in the physical world. If you are driving with a GPS system, you are simultaneously driving your car and manoeuvring your car through a digital construct. I believe that very few of us are aware of the extent to which that has already happened, and I suspect that I’m not aware of it to anywhere near the real extent to which it has happened. So in this book I was looking for a more or less imaginary emergent technology or art form that will allow me to simply bring that up. The conversation in the coffee shop on Sunset Boulevard is a little more grandstanding than I usually do. I don’t think I have had a scene in a novel before where three people sit down and basically talk about a William Gibson novel without ever really mentioning it.


I guess that is the point: "very few of us are aware of the extent to which" large sections of human activity and social life have transferred themselves to what Gibson would once have called cyberspace, and very few of us are aware of the negotiation of "digital constructs" that have merged seamlessly into our experience of the real.

08 November 2008

Web 2.0 Summit

Web 2.0 Summit
I especially enjoyed listening to Tim O'Reilly talking to Paul Maritz (VMware, Inc.) and others about cloud computing. Maritz makes the point that we are moving away from a device centric world to an information centric world. This is something we already intuitively know actively assume in our dealings with our data and information. Maritz also points out that putting our information in the cloud (in any way, even by typing a term into a search box) is taking part in an information marketplace. We are giving away some of our privacy and some personal information about ourselves in order that we get some benefit in return (e.g. an answer to our query). On a larger scale, an organization putting its information in the cloud--into that marketplace--and allowing others to add value to it through things like mashups or user tagging can make our information more valuable--to others but also to us.

31 October 2008

3 Ways Web-Based Computing Will Change Colleges - Chronicle.com

3 Ways Web-Based Computing Will Change Colleges - Chronicle.com:

"At first I wondered why Google needed to demonstrate its popular e-mail service. Didn’t students already know how to click send? But when I hopped on the bus at George Washington University last month, I saw that the demos highlighted all the other Web services in its Google Apps for Education e-mail package for colleges, which includes a Web-based word processor called Google Docs, a Web-based spreadsheet program, and other tools.

Those tools are the cloud computing part—the term usually refers to programs that run over the Internet rather than locally on a user’s computer. And Google officials explained that many students don’t yet know about those new Web-based services."


and then an anecdote

At a summer program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology that I sat in on last year, I asked students whether they had stayed up all night at the library finishing their final group projects, as the program’s organizers had predicted. One of the students looked at me as if I were crazy. Yes, he had worked late—until about 3 a.m.—but he had been at home by himself. The students all contributed to a shared document using Google Docs, which anyone in the group could edit online from anywhere. All of the students were essentially logged in to the same computer (in this case off at Google somewhere), one adding a paragraph at the end, another changing the font, and another rewriting the title. There was no longer any need to worry about getting everyone in the same room at the same time.


It is interesting that Google spends time promoting this service, letting students see the advantage of this type of virtual collaboration. Will this be something that all students will suddenly grasp--will there be a tipping point beyond which it will be a strategy too obvious to need explaining--or will students need to learn new strategies of collaboration and communication? And, is Google not just teaching students about this, but also gathering information on how informal groups like this collaborate?

Universities review plagiarism policies to catch Facebook cheats | Education | guardian.co.uk

Universities review plagiarism policies to catch Facebook cheats | Education | guardian.co.uk:
"Universities are reviewing their plagiarism policies to clamp down on students who use Facebook to cheat.

Plagiarism experts have warned universities and colleges to be aware of students copying from each other when discussing coursework on social networking sites.

Gill Rowell, from the consultancy Plagiarism Advice, said universities needed to rework their plagiarism policies with 'internet working in mind' but insisted institutions were taking cheating seriously enough."

Although Facebook gets the headline--and obviously represents one form of what could be called collaborative dishonesty--the article goes on to talk about Wikipedia and Googled essays as other sources of plagiarized material.

17 October 2008

Social Media Information Flow

Social Media Information Flow - The Complexity of the Web 2.0 World
This may be a bit more extreme than the average person's social media information flow, but I created a diagram (using MindManager) showing how the information I create flows through the online world.


It does show the complexity consumers are dealing with in the Web 2.0 world, and it will be interesting to see how the leading services help us deal with this. Facebook is of course the best example to date.


This is the question, how do we deal with this and how much is too much to manage. See also, Josh Catone at ReadWriteWeb -- Visualizing Social Media Fatigue

16 October 2008

Ning and the Proliferation of DIY Social Networks - eMarketer

Ning and the Proliferation of DIY Social Networks - eMarketer
To satisfy users who seek more control over their online socializing experiences, a number of do-it-yourself (DIY) networks have emerged. The sites allow for unprecedented levels of customization for networks on nearly any topic, as well as the ability to connect to others who share the same interests and goals.

Is this the future of social networking...or just the logical conclusion that will never arrive?

09 October 2008

Scobleizer — Tech geek blogger » Blog Archive Dave Winer says I sound like a monkey «

Scobleizer — Tech geek blogger » Blog Archive Dave Winer says I sound like a monkey «:

"The Social Graph is NOT my social network.

My Social Network is my friends list.

But the Social Graph shows a LOT more than that."

Who can say if this is the right term for this concept. However, it seems like the crucial element of applications like Facebook.

Face to Facebook Learning | Learn at All Levels | Fast Company

Face to Facebook Learning | Learn at All Levels | Fast Company:
"It was from this perspective I felt disoriented as a perspective client used Compete Inc.'s analysis of what people do on Facebook as proof (proof?) it's not a place where people learn. The manager was echoing nonsense I hear from educators and business people alike who argue social networking does not constitute learning and that a platform like Facebook is too immature to foster authentic education."

30 September 2008

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk:

"But Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and creator of the computer operating system GNU, said that cloud computing was simply a trap aimed at forcing more people to buy into locked, proprietary systems that would cost them more and more over time.

'It's stupidity. It's worse than stupidity: it's a marketing hype campaign,' he told The Guardian.

'Somebody is saying this is inevitable – and whenever you hear somebody saying that, it's very likely to be a set of businesses campaigning to make it true.'"


It is kind of ironic to post this on a blog, I guess, because it exists in this cloud, and therefore does not remain on my machine and in my control. It is useful to make the link here, and not store it on my personal machine, and not download the article on Stallman to my personal machine. I see Stallman's point, but the question is more and more, "where does the cloud end?" In other words, the world of the personal machine / archive / library extends from one's own machine to the network and to the wider web in a way that is more and more seamless. There are things one wants on one's machine, and other things which are more conveniently held elsewhere.

16 September 2008

Facebook can ruin your life. And so can MySpace, Bebo... - News, Gadgets & Tech - The Independent

Facebook can ruin your life. And so can MySpace, Bebo... - News, Gadgets & Tech - The Independent:
"At Cambridge, at least one don has admitted 'discreetly' scanning applicants' pages – a practice now widespread in job recruitment. A survey released by Viadeo said that 62 per cent of British employers now check the Facebook, MySpace or Bebo pages of some applicants, and that a quarter had rejected candidates as a result. Reasons given by employers included concerns about 'excess alcohol abuse', ethics and job 'disrespect'"

Detailed article on the decline of privacy or death of privacy on social networks.