"Uncynical, unvigilant
Everything would, of course, go very slowly. It would take two days to reach Rome, a month before one finally sailed exultantly into Sydney harbour. And yet there would be benefits tied up in this languor.
Those who had known the age of planes would recall the confusion they had felt upon arriving in Mumbai or Rio, Auckland or Montego Bay, only hours after leaving home, their slight sickness and bewilderment lending credence to the old Arabic saying that the soul invariably travels at the speed of a camel."
17 April 2010
BBC News - Today - A world without planes
16 April 2010
Edge: THE REALITY CLUB: "DIGITAL POWER AND ITS DISCONTENTS"
"It seems apparent, alas, that Facebook, Twitter, etc. have not improved American democracy, and yet we expect these tools to promote democracy elsewhere.
The basic problem is that web 2.0 tools are not supportive of democracy by design. They are tools designed to gather spy-agency-like data in a seductive way, first and foremost, but as a side effect they tend to provide software support for mob-like phenomena. There are some nice mob effects, but the intensity of the failures is more profound than the delights of the successes."
Edge: DIGITAL POWER AND ITS DISCONTENTS — Morozov & Shirky: An Edge Conversation
"The dreams of network utopians vs. the realists. Is the Internet is a medium of emancipation and of revolution — or a tool of control and repression? Did Twitter and Facebook have stoke the flames of rebellion in Iran, or did they help the authorities unmask the rebels? — Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung"
31 March 2010
In E-Book Era, You Can’t Even Judge a Cover - NYTimes.com
"Bindu Wiles was on a Q train in Brooklyn this month when she spotted a woman reading a book whose cover had an arresting black silhouette of a girl’s head set against a bright orange background.
Ms. Wiles noticed that the woman looked about her age, 45, and was carrying a yoga mat, so she figured that they were like-minded and leaned in to catch the title: “Little Bee,” a novel by Chris Cleave. Ms. Wiles, a graduate student in nonfiction writing at Sarah Lawrence College, tapped a note into her iPhone and bought the book later that week."
The unanticipated encounter--the subway train, the affinity with the fellow passenger, the discovery of an unknown book--all more difficult in the age of ebooks, where the cover ceases to exist as a sign to the world.
29 March 2010
Cognitive Surplus -- Clay Shirky
The Pew Internet and American Life project reports that the majority of all teens are now engaged in active creation of online content. The rise of social media reflects new opportunities and outlets for creativity.
Increased youth engagement through these activities represents a repurposing of what Clay Shirky terms a cognitive surplus. Shirky, a professor in the Interactive Telecommunications Program at New York University, believes that a movement from passive activities such as watching television to more active and creative pursuits is emerging as a use of the cognitive surplus in the Web 2.0 era. Collaborative projects such as Wikipedia demonstrate that a previously unexploited collective intelligence can be tapped when the right conditions are established.
It is almost as if one of the goals of teaching with technology or using the technology that students use is a way of trying to squeeze educational goals into the creative activities of students.
Cognitive surplus is an interesting term--does it mean light or just heat? does it mean cognitive power put to the task of solving problems and creating new things, or is it just employing brain cycles to filter and recycle ideas and objects found on the web?
27 March 2010
14 March 2010
Danah Boyd: How Technology Makes A Mess Of Privacy and Publicity
a compelling talk that challenged the notion that personal information is on a binary spectrum of public or private
Boyd then discussed how different groups of people think about privacy. She says that teenagers are much more conscious about what they have to gain by being in public, whereas adults are more concerned about what they have to lose.
There is another summary of this presentation at ReadWriteWeb
Boyd's own notes for the presentation are also available at her website: http://www.danah.org/papers/talks/2010/SXSW2010.html
12 March 2010
Giz Explains: How You're Gonna Get Screwed By Ebook Formats - Ebooks - Gizmodo
Detailed explanation of ebook formats for major ebook readers, discussing how much freedom one will have to move ebooks from one device to another -- not much as it turns out. It also raises the question of whether the epub or the PDF is superior. An interesting point for debate.
05 March 2010
Miller-McCune Research Essay — Handwriting Is History | Smart Journalism. Real Solutions. | Miller-McCune Online Magazine
"Most of us know, but often forget, that handwriting is not natural. We are not born to do it. There is no genetic basis for writing. Writing is not like seeing or talking, which are innate. Writing must be taught."
And yet, it has become part of most people's minds so that if (or when) our ability to write ends or declines...
We may, however, forsake some neurological memory. I imagine some pathways in our brains will atrophy. Then again, I imagine my brain is developing new cognitive pathways each time I hit control C or double click Firefox.
02 March 2010
Jaron Lanier's You Are Not a Gadget. - By Michael Agger - Slate Magazine
"Perhaps our regimented Facebook selves have made things more vanilla. Perhaps you did stumble down more idiosyncratic paths of knowledge before Wikipedia dominated the top Google search results. But these are the kinds of nostalgic observations that are ridiculous to anyone young. The Web hasn't lost flavor; you've lost flavor."
Interesting review of Lanier's book, but this passage caught my eye. It may be worth looking at Lanier to see if he does make any argument related to the loss of the unanticipated. And while Lanier does have a solution for the economic problem he sees in the web's open structure, he does not have a solution to the culture of Google.
And an interview with Lanier by Aleks Krotoski
25 February 2010
Atemporality for the Creative Artist | Beyond The Beyond
"There are new asynchronous communication forms that are globalized and offshored, and there is the loss of a canon and a record. There is no single authoritative voice of history. Instead we get wildly empowered cranks, lunatics, and every kind of long-tail intellectual market appearing in network culture. Everything from brilliant insight to scurillous rumor."
Bruce Sterling, as usual, stimulating and weird at the same time. And, doubtless, yes, perhaps now, because of the internet / web there is a cacophony of voices... but...
Someone -- who, I forget who, but someone much smarter than me -- wrote about the fact that the present is always on the brink of a future that is unknown. There is always a basic "atemporality" in Sterling's sense, but I don't think it is the right word. He laments that the master narrative has been lost, but the fact is that the master narratives we create are always failing, not because some line of history is being lost, but because we never really understand the present in a complex enough way -- the way we will understand it when it is past. Atemporality may be messy or an intractable problem at the moment, but why lament the lack of a master narrative -- this is just for a dionysian moment a realization of the truth: there is no real master narrative, there never was.
FT.com / Comment / Editorial - Google’s size puts it in the searchlight
"The overarching issue is: does the gatekeeping role of web search give it a public utility-like role? That is the difficult question that Mr Almunia must help to answer."
Several things lately have made me come back to the idea of the web as a city, one that started out as a medieval city of small houses close together--smaller communities that grew and merged organically into a densely populated and crowded urban space, where getting anywhere was difficult and finding things tricky and uncertain.
Google is like Baron Haussmann, who cut boulevards through the structure of Paris bringing ease of movement as well as water and sewer service, to the city.
As the FT article points out, Google is like a utility (and like a gatekeeper (another medieval urban image)). Its roles actually reshape the information space. So, yes, it is a utility.
24 February 2010
19 February 2010
The Future of the Internet IV | Pew Research Center's Internet & American Life Project
"the Internet will enhance our intelligence – not make us stupid. It will also change the functions of reading and writing and be built around still-unanticipated gadgetry and applications. The battle over control of the internet will rage on."
Short history of the future of the Web
17 February 2010
BBC News - MEPs condemn Nokia Siemens 'surveillance tech' in Iran
"Euro MPs have 'strongly' criticised telecoms firm Nokia Siemens Networks for providing 'surveillance technology' to the Iranian authorities.
In a resolution adopted on Wednesday, the MEPs said the hardware was instrumental in the 'persecution and arrests of Iranian dissidents'."
And also a comment from Amnesty International:
Technology, particularly Internet and telecommunications technology, provides ‘the good guys’ with new tools to help them do their job: documenting human rights abuses, telling as many people as possible about it, mobilising people to try to stop them. But it also provides ‘the bad guys’ with new tools to do their job too – bugging people’s conversations, snooping on their emails, tracking their location.
Is technology really good for human rights?
15 February 2010
E-books: Publishers poised for victory in latest battle - Times Online
"It is believed that allowing buyers to print copies from Google Editions, or allowing the copying and pasting of extracts, is also now off the table."
Old media, doing what old media seems to do best in the information age.
14 February 2010
A Face Is Exposed for AOL Searcher No. 4417749 - New York Times
"But the detailed records of searches conducted by Ms. Arnold and 657,000 other Americans, copies of which continue to circulate online, underscore how much people unintentionally reveal about themselves when they use search engines — and how risky it can be for companies like AOL, Google and Yahoo to compile such data."
The more you search, the more the search engine knows what you are looking for. And on the other side of the coin, the more you search, the less anonymous you are to the search engine.
12 February 2010
China Alarmed by Security Threat From Internet - NYTimes.com
"In the view of both political analysts and technology experts here and in the United States, China’s attempts to tighten its grip on Internet use are driven in part by the conviction that the West — and particularly the United States — is wielding communications innovations from malware to Twitter to weaken it militarily and to stir dissent internally."
The view from the other side: America and American technology as a tool for destabilization and disruptive change.
09 February 2010
07 February 2010
Edge: CLOUD CULTURE: THE PROMISE AND THE THREAT by Charles Leadbeater
"Digital clouds will be either commercial, social or public."
Charles Leadbeater gives a classification of digital clouds. And the growth of these clouds creates the possibility of what he calls "Cloud Culture" which could lead, he says, to "Exponential growth in mass cultural expression". And all of this culture could be / should be
a rare and delicate mix: more decentralised, plural and collaborative; less hierarchical, proprietary and money driven; the boundaries between amateur and professional, consumer and producer, grassroots and mainstream are breached, if not erased.
Yet, he is not blind to the other possibility, pointed out by Evgeny Morozov--the fact that authoritarian governments can also make use of the cloud.
Leadbeater is "hopeful but realistic," as much as it is possible to be about the unfolding future, but the truth remains to be seen.
Two futures of the internet: next cold war or up in the clouds | Technology | The Observer
Future 1: cyber war
"the world's dominant internet company is now in the crossfire of early skirmishes of the next cold war.
This thought was reinforced by Financial Times columnist Gideon Rachman. He'd been to the International Institute for Strategic Studies for a briefing on its annual survey, Military Balance. 'The thing I found most interesting,' he said, 'was the confirmation that cyber-security is the hot issue … John Chipman, the head of the IISS, says the institute is about to launch a study of cyber-security which raises all sorts of issues. What if a country's infrastructure could be destroyed as effectively by a cyber-attack as by an invasion of tanks? How do you defend against that? How do you identify the culprits? What does international law have to say – might we have to revise our definitions of what constitutes an act of war?
'Chipman argues, plausibly, that we are now at an equivalent period to the early 1950s. Just as strategists had to devise whole new doctrines to cope with the nuclear age, so they will have to come up with new ideas to cope with the information age.'"
26 January 2010
Visitors and Residents (from blip.tv)
from blip.tv
This video explains the useful distinction between Visitors and Residents on the web.
From Tall blog: tallblog.conted.ox.ac.uk
22 January 2010
‘Controlled Serendipity’ Liberates the Web
Most of us do this to some degree. We are no longer just consumers of content, we have become curators of it too.
If someone approached me even five years ago and explained that one day in the near future I would be filtering, collecting and sharing content for thousands of perfect strangers to read — and doing it for free — I would have responded with a pretty perplexed look. Yet today I can’t imagine living in a world where I don’t filter, collect and share.
Yes, maybe, but...
It isn't exactly controlled serendipity, it is more creating structures which allow one to control that which otherwise would be left to serendipity. So, in many ways, it is not in the least serendipitous. It is, however, the use of channels or paths that are unusual, but are adapted for an organizational, a resource-finding purpose that were not originally designed for this. It is path making.
19 January 2010
Top 10 technologies for tyranny - Software - Technology - News - CRN Australia
Top 10 technologies for tyranny
By Iain Thomson
Jan 18, 2010 9:29 AM
Essential tools for up-and-coming despots."
The top five
5. Malware/keyloggers
4. CCTV
3. Databases
The beauty of the database is that it creates a streamlined, efficient method for reducing everyday human activity to a collection of statistics. A well-maintained database is particularly effective in times of strife, as modern tools have made it possible to cross-reference names and locations with previously flagged entries.
2. Web monitoring
...some countries have set up their own internal web monitoring systems, notably China although other countries also practice this. Such systems not only allow content to be blocked at source but also allow the authorities to keep track of what individuals are doing online. They are helped in this by companies operating in the country in question more often than not.
Basically web monitoring is just another form of undercover surveillance, but as the world becomes to rely more and more on the internet so web monitoring is becoming more useful as a method for crushing dissent.
1. Firewalls
Truly, for the ruler who demands the finest in information suppression, the large-scale public firewall is a must.
17 January 2010
Is it really doomsday for books? Not while English casts its spell | Books | Books | The Observer
"The books themselves, with some egregious exceptions, are better printed, bound and jacketed than ever before. Take any volume published in the 1970s and place it next to, say, Hilary Mantel's Wolf Hall or Colm TóibÃn's Brooklyn. The contrast is shocking. Narrow margins, cheap paper, and hideous typography have all had a comprehensive aesthetic makeover."
Interesting that the rise of e-books and the rising threat to the existence of the book might reinvigorate the quality of books produced.
30 December 2009
Digital Humanities the Next Big Thing at the MLA
Clearly, the merger of literature and technology is no longer the obsession of a few hobbyists, though too many are still working in the academic equivalent of their parents' basements.
Digital literacy is going to be as essential as information literacy and critical thinking. And English departments can have an important role to play in fostering those new skills. Or -- if we overstress traditionalism and resist innovation because it's more comfortable -- we can cede that ground to other departments such as communications and computer science, making ourselves even less relevant and supportable than we presently are.
Is it the bandwagon of fear, opportunity, or commitment. Sounds like all those New Year's resolutions one can't help but reading now--full of optimism, determined to make the future better, but as Pannapacker points out lacking much of the skilled people to bring about the transition.
13 December 2009
We are all digital immigrants now.
But there's one cliche in particular that annoys Danah Boyd: the "digital native".When you think about it, it makes sense. Why would they be different? Perhaps young people spend more time in the online world, and perhaps they are more invested in it, but they still have to figure out the rules, same as everyone else.
"There's nothing native about young people's engagement with technology," she says, adamantly.
The Microsoft researcher, who has made a career from studying the way younger people use the web, doesn't think much of the widely held assumption that children are innately better at coping with the web or negotiating the hurdles of digital life. Instead, she suggests, they're pretty much like everyone else.
"Young people are learning, they're learning about the social world around them," she says. "The social world around them today has mediated technologies, thus in order to learn about the social world they're learning about the mediated technologies..."
11 December 2009
Social Networks and Anti-Social Power
by Evgeny Morozov
Social networking, then, has inadvertently made it easier to gather intelligence about activist networks. Even a tiny security flaw in the settings of one Facebook profile can compromise the security of many others. A study by two MIT students, reported in September, showed it is possible to predict a person’s sexual orientation by analysing their Facebook friends; bad news for those in regions where homosexuality carries the threat of beatings and prison. And many authoritarian regimes are turning to data-mining companies to help them identify troublemakers. TRS Technologies in China is one such company. It boasts that “thanks to our technology, the work of ten internet cops can now be done by just one.”
The technologies that allow freedom also allow control. This all makes perfect sense, sadly. Everything can be hacked, by any side. But the growing theme for all social network users--wherever they are--is the creeping (or galloping) loss of freedom and loss of anonymity.
08 December 2009
A whole Library of Congress, eh?
Google has become such a household term that its name has morphed into a verb. “Its index contained one trillion Web pages in 2008,” Mr. Auletta writes, “and according to Brin, every four hours Google indexed the equivalent of the entire Library of Congress.”
The NYT provides a link to other articles about the Library of Congress, but not to a definition of the unit--neither, presumably did Brin. The unit is frequently an abstraction based on the number of books in the library. Michael Hart's calculation is that a library of congress equals about 13 terabytes. But Matt Raymond writing in the Library of Congress blog, notes that
we can as of this moment say that the approximate amount of our collections that are digitized and freely and publicly available on the Internet is about 74 terabytes. We can also say that we have about 15.3 million digital items online.
Perhaps Mr. Brin or other people who throw around this unit of measurement, should be more specific.
05 December 2009
26 November 2009
In the 'deep web'
As Kosmix and other search engines improve, he says, they will make the internet truly transparent: "You will be on the same level playing field as the bad guys." The internet as a sort of electronic panopticon, everything on it unforgivingly visible and retrievable – suddenly its current murky depths seem in some ways preferable.
Fascinating article in the Guardian about the dark web. There is a tendency in the visible web towards the visible, the named, the identified and the controlled. But as we more and more walk along well lighted and controlled streets, there are the dark side streets where one can walk in shadow, where one can experience the unanticipated and the random. In many ways, the web, like the city, seeks a balance between the safe and controlled, on the one hand, and the dangerous and uncontrolled, on the other.
23 November 2009
Coming soon to Canada: something similar
The digital economy bill is misnamed. A more honest title for the legislation, recently introduced in the Lords, would be the copyright protection and punishment bill. It is less about creating the digital businesses of the 21st century than protecting the particular 20th century business models used in music and film.
22 November 2009
The Noble Savage Space
Cyberspace was born free, but everywhere it is in chains. Once a promised land inhabited by visionaries, libertarians and freedom fighters, it has become a war zone. “The Harry Potter age of the internet,” says Professor Ron Deibert, “is over.”I have been reading lately about Deibert and the Citizen lab. They are doing interesting work (citizenlab.org)
Deibert is director of the Citizen Lab at Toronto University, which monitors state and corporate control of cyberspace. In a recent Citizen Lab survey of 69 countries, it learnt that 40 had internet restrictions.
17 November 2009
H1N1 symptoms -- they didn't mention hallucinations
t is important that as swine flu spreads, you hump the symptoms of the disease so you can recall it in yourself and others at an aboriginal platform.
Delight construe this attender and reckon your symptoms carefully before using the Human Pandemic Flu Delivery mentioned below.
So far, most swine flu cases score been moderate, with symptoms same to those of seasonal flu. Only a miniature circumscribe of people hit had author sobering symptoms.
If you or a member of your kin has any of the followers symptoms and a temperature of 38°C or above, you may hold swine flu.
The representative symptoms are:
* a sharp pyrexia (a luxuriously body temperature of 38°C/100.4°F or above), and
* a fast cough.
New symptoms may permit:
* headache,
* tiredness,
(http://www.symptomsswineflu.net/)
My body temperature is luxurious, and my cough is fast--at times, but I have not construed delight, and I hope I am not in the miniature circumscribe of people.
the type in Mad Men
The same applies to TV shows, including the otherwise excellent “Mad Men.” It is rare to find a review of the show that does not rave about the accuracy of its early 1960s styling, yet the “Mad Men” team is woefully sloppy when it comes to typography. Mark Simonson, a graphic designer in St. Paul, Minnesota, blogs about typographic misdemeanors on his Web site, www.marksimonson.com, and he once catalogued the flaws in “Mad Men.” The 1992 typeface, Lucida Handwriting, appears in an ad in the opening titles. Gill Sans, a British typeface designed in 1930 but rarely used in the United States until the 1970s, is used for office signage. A lipstick ad features one wholly appropriate 1958 font, Amazone, but two incongruous ones, 1978’s Balmoral and 1980’s Fenice. He noted lots of other clunkers too, but admits that he has spotted fewer new errors in the most recent episodes of “Mad Men.”
from Mistakes in Typography Grate the Purists
NYTimes November 15, 2009
05 November 2009
Social Network world changing
In May of 2008, the median age for Facebook was 26. Today, it's 33, a good seven years older.
ReadWriteWeb reports a strong uptake in the last year in those 18 - 24 using Twitter.
15 September 2009
The reason Craigslist is a mess
This ends the debate for him, but his tone is oddly non-triumphal; in fact, Buckmaster's statement of fealty to users has a weary sound that I don't understand until weeks later. Only after I have spent every spare hour on craigslist—browsing the ads, tracking the spam, reading the help forums, contacting users—do I finally begin to grasp something of his situation. The truth is that a lot of people complain about craigslist. Buckmaster is correct that few of them complain about the design. They complain about spam, they complain about fraud, they complain about the posting rules, they complain about the search, they complain about uploading images. They complain about every way a classified transaction can go wrong. They seldom complain about amazing new features they imagine they might possibly want to use, because they are too busy complaining about the simple features they depend on that don't work as well as they'd like. By eliminating marketing, sales, and business development, craigslist's programmers have cut out all the cushioning layers that separate them from the users they serve, and any right they have to teach lessons in public service comes from the odd situation of running a company that is directly subservient only to the public. Here's the lesson: The public is a motherfucker.
from Why Craigslist is such a mess
Now this is really interesting.
06 August 2009
Are fewer young people using social networks such as Twitter? How we all use the internet | News | guardian.co.uk
"Apparently, it is SO over: the kids don't like social networking anymore. Even more gallingly, it appears part of the reason is that older users do."
Figures show a drop in use of social networks by users between the ages of 25 to 54. So, what do they mean by older?
Serendipity
Is it possible to build in some randomness or chaos into an information system?
Biz Stone, a Twitter co-founder, wrote to the Twitterati, 'Repositioning the product to focus more on discovery is an important first step in presenting Twitter to a wider audience of folks around the world who are eager to start engaging with new people, ideas, opinions, events and sources of information.'
Interesting observation that the digital world hides so many things that were formerly visible, a person's music collection, choices of movies, even now, I suppose, books. Now, we reveal things about ourselves on our Facebook pages, or through the random pictures of us others might post.
But note, randomness has to be anarchic and disorderly. Serendipity, is really the wrong word. The word was coined by Horace Walpole (in 1754) according to the Wikipedia. Walpole gives an example definition:
One of the most remarkable instances of this accidental sagacity (for you must observe that no discovery of a thing you are looking for, comes under this description) was of my Lord Shaftsbury, who happening to dine at Lord Chancellor Clarendon's, found out the marriage of the Duke of York and Mrs. Hyde, by the respect with which her mother treated her at table.
"Accidental sagacity" is not how we would define the term today. Walpole's example shows what we would more likely call deduction, putting together clues to find out something that one would otherwise not have known. It shows simply a discovery, suddenly understanding something, but it is not necessarily a fortunate or happy discovery, the most important element of our current definition.
The idea of the accidental encounter contains the possibility of the happy chance discovery, but also of the unhappy or unpleasant discovery. And, in any system to do what Biz Stone wants to do, viz. engaging with new people, ideas, opinions, &c, the happy is only just a part of it.
03 August 2009
The prospects of Microsoft Word in the wiki-based world - Ars Technica
"One day you wake up and everything is on a wiki somewhere. How did that happen? It happens in much the same way as typewriters suddenly disappeared—because a better alternative arrived. Word—and I know I'll be attacked for saying this—is the new typewriter."
Well maybe not on a wiki somewhere but somewhere in the cloud. And doubtless it will happen. From the point of view of people like this writer who are concerned with finding the real document / the most recent / the final version of a document. For many others the reality is still the printout.
What everyone had lost track of in the heat of battle was why we were still using Word (or OpenOffice Writer, which is—let's face it—just a clone of Word) to create documents that were likely never going to be printed.
Yes, maybe this is true, but a document is in many people's minds something that could be printed out--even if in reality it will never be. It is only when the document on the screen becomes the real document--in people's minds--and the printout is seen as only a copy, an instance of that reality that the shift will have been made.
I think that the regularity and rules of design that have accreted around the 8 1/2 x 11 page have given it the authority of some consistency (a replacement of the typewriter created page). And a new design standard of an electronic document will have to replace this, and perhaps the author is correct in finding this (at least for himself) in the wiki page
Wikipedia's CSS files automatically make everything look pretty, and more importantly, consistently pretty.
29 July 2009
danah boyd on ... the real social network
danah boyd distinguishes between three types or views of social networks determined by how they are conceptualized or investigated, and these are, she says, "often collapsed in public discourse":
--Sociological "personal" networks
--Behavioral social networks
and
--Publicly articulated social networks
The sociological, she points out, is the source of many of the terms we use to describe online social networks: friend, social capital, &c. And frequently we would probably like to think that online social networks are structures like this type of network, assuming for example, that a friend in this type of network is someone you could approach if you wanted to get some notes from a class you missed. But, in reality, online social networks are more complex, made up of people we work with or are in a class with, or would like to be associated with in some way.
So, it it important in researching social networks to try to focus on what you want to measure: behaviours, attitudes, self-conceptions, &c.
01 July 2009
Facebook Says It Wants You to Be Less Private - But Why?
"Facebook Director of Communications Brandee Barker told us this in response to our 'why' question:
Sharing is at the core of our product. Finding people you know, learning about people you don't know, searching for what people are saying about topics that interest you can generally only happen when people are open and choose to share. By recommending more open defaults, more people will be able to connect on the site.
Is that really true? Facebook is about learning about people you don't know and searching for what people are saying about topics that interest you? Far more often, we've heard the saying 'Facebook is about people you know, Twitter is about people you want to know and MySpace is about people you used to know.'
It is interesting that Facebook started off as a private space, controlled and limited, and that now it wants to become a more open space. Of course, it could be that Facebook wants to use this openness to sell users things, to convert the space into a market where interactions are less and less a the user's control. It is like the developments of urbanization, except in reverse. It may create some benefits as well as some irritations.
28 June 2009
Great Wall of Facebook: The Social Network's Plan to Dominate the Internet
"More than 200 million people—about one-fifth of all Internet users—have Facebook accounts. They spend an average of 20 minutes on the site every day."
And more importantly in this article, the point that Facebook sees itself more as a rival to Google than as a rival to other SNSs:
"We never liked those guys [Google]," says one former Facebook engineer. "We all had that audacity, 'Anything Google does, we can do better.' No one talked about MySpace or the other social networks. We just talked about Google."
The ultimate direction of Facebook is as an alternative model for the web to Google and its approach to organizing the world's information. But, the real question is: is this model possible? For one thing, will the social network model scale, and especially will it remain human, community-like, or will it come to feel inhuman, monolithic, and autocratic?
In this regard, I think that readwriteweb has got it right:
These are the diminishing returns. The more the model scales, the more it will irritate users, and the more users will switch off, and the sooner growth will slow down and reverse. As with email, Facebook can "make up for this with volume." But unlike with email, which is virtually free, Facebook has to pay money to serve each user.
Sorry, "Coca-Cola wants to be your friend" is in no way an enduring revenue model. If it sounds phony, maybe that is because it is phony.
The one lesson from social media marketing is that authenticity matters. What no one has shown -- and methinks this would be impossible -- is how to scale authenticity.
15 June 2009
Studies Explore Whether the Internet Makes Students Better Writers - Chronicle.com
"In a shorter project, undergraduates in a first-year writing class at Michigan State University were asked to keep a diary of the writing they did in any environment, whether blogging, text messaging, or gaming. For each act of writing over a two-week period, they recorded the time, genre, audience, location, and purpose of their writing.
'What was interesting to us was how small a percentage of the total writing the school writing was,' says Jeffrey T. Grabill, the study's lead author, who is director of the Writing in Digital Environments Research Center at Michigan State. In the diaries and in follow-up interviews, he says, students often described their social, out-of-class writing as more persistent and meaningful to them than their in-class work was.
'Digital technologies, computer networks, the Web — all of those things have led to an explosion in writing,' Mr. Grabill says. 'People write more now than ever. In order to interact on the Web, you have to write.'"
On the one hand students write more, but on the other, as Mark Bauerlein notes, citing "the reading and writing scores in the National Assessment of Educational Progress, which have remained fairly flat for decades. It is a paradox, he says: 'Why is it that with young people reading and writing more words than ever before in human history, we find no gains in reading and writing scores?'" I suppose one could ask, even if students are doing more are they doing enough? And, where does the feedback come from to make them try to write better?
08 June 2009
Well, so much for the paid content model
"I think I'll remember last week as the moment when I finally knew, with a certainty approaching fatigue, that the newspaper industry – the business and passion that both shaped and warped me over the past 20 years – had chosen ritual suicide. The choice appears grimly reached and irrevocable."
Read the whole article at Xark...
31 May 2009
The Benefits of Distraction and Overstimulation -- New York Magazine
As the writer points out
"Over the last twenty years, Meyer and a host of other researchers have proved again and again that multitasking, at least as our culture has come to know and love and institutionalize it, is a myth. When you think you’re doing two things at once, you’re almost always just switching rapidly between them, leaking a little mental efficiency with every switch."
In other words our minds are capable of paying attention to only one thing at once. We are capable of sharing our attention between two or more tasks only because we are capable, or seem capable in our own minds, of doing them with relatively efficiency by doing this rapid switching back and forth. However, don't be fooled.
Only in the last ten years—thanks to neuroscientists and their functional MRIs—have we been able to watch the attending human brain in action, with its coordinated storms of neural firing, rapid blood surges, and oxygen flows. This has yielded all kinds of fascinating insights—for instance, that when forced to multitask, the overloaded brain shifts its processing from the hippocampus (responsible for memory) to the striatum (responsible for rote tasks), making it hard to learn a task or even recall what you’ve been doing once you’re done.
So, certain kinds of tasks can be accomplished using this method, but ones that rely on bringing together ideas or whose goal is to remember something obviously would not be successfully accomplished. However, the writer notes:
The only time multitasking does work efficiently, Meyer says, is when multiple simple tasks operate on entirely separate channels—for example, folding laundry (a visual-manual task) while listening to a stock report (a verbal task). But real-world scenarios that fit those specifications are very rare.
So, sometimes we may have the sense that we are actually succeeding in multitasking and this may give us the illusion that we are capable of truly doing several things at once at any time.
The unanticipated encounter
However, as much as we want to be the type of people who are capable of concentration and attention to tasks, we have to acknowledge the power of the interruptions that surround us, and most of us would not willingly give all of them up, at least all of the time. As the writer points out:
The Internet is basically a Skinner box engineered to tap right into our deepest mechanisms of addiction. As B. F. Skinner’s army of lever-pressing rats and pigeons taught us, the most irresistible reward schedule is not, counterintuitively, the one in which we’re rewarded constantly but something called “variable ratio schedule,” in which the rewards arrive at random. And that randomness is practically the Internet’s defining feature: It dispenses its never-ending little shots of positivity—a life-changing e-mail here, a funny YouTube video there—in gloriously unpredictable cycles.
This is the reality, the life-changing is frequently the unanticipated. And, as the writer goes on to discuss, one of the problems of drugs people take to concentrate their attention is the very narrowness and restricted nature of the focus it provides.
Adderall users frequently complain that the drug stifles their creativity—that it’s best for doing ultrarational, structured tasks. (As Foer put it, “I had a nagging suspicion that I was thinking with blinders on.”)
23 May 2009
How (Not) to Write like a Designer: 5 Tricks You Didn't Learn in Studio - Core77
"1. Use your skills. You’re a designer, which means you’re good at the same kinds of things writers are good at, but you use different tools. You’re a fixer: you work within constraints to find elegant solutions to complicated problems, and that’s kind of what writing is, too. So, faced with a writing task, do what you do best. Break it down into a problem you can solve. Ask yourself: Who’s this for? What’s the big idea? What are the pieces I’m using? What do I want to say? Like designing, writing can straddle the line between art and craft—half blinding flashes of inspiration and unexplainable moments of brilliance (maybe a little less than half), and half moving words around, making and breaking sentences, typing commas then deleting them. Nuts and bolts stuff. If you get too caught in one side, move to the other. Writing’s about thinking big and thinking small, putting complex ideas into simple boxes, and you can do that."
Maybe we should all learn to think of writing as a design problem.
22 May 2009
Exploring the 2010 Web
"“OK, Scoble, so what are you learning about the 2010 web so far?”
Well, I’m seeing it has a few attributes:
1. It’s real time. Twitter, Facebook and Friendfeed are all moving toward architectures and displays that refresh in real time, or let you see what’s happening right now. We are at the extreme beginnings of that trend."
2. It's mobile
3. It's decentralized
4. Pages now built out of premade blocks.
5. It's social
6. It's smart
7. Hybrid infrastructure
(all points from Scoble--for details see posting)
22 April 2009
Will Blackboard be the new Twitter?
"Blackboard plans to add a Twitter-like messaging tool to its course-management system, which is used at hundreds of colleges around the country. The company recently announced plans to acquire NTI Group, a company that sells text-message notification systems to colleges for use in emergencies. NTI's systems don't have all the features of Twitter, but they could be used in similar ways."
21 April 2009
Facebook, Grades, and Media Hype Hype - Chronicle.com
"A researcher at Ohio State University has found that students who use Facebook reported earning lower grade-point averages than nonusers of the social-networking service. But the researcher, Aryn C. Karpinski, said in an interview with The Chronicle that she did not have enough data to determine whether Facebook use causes students to do poorly in their studies, despite a string of media reports that she says overstate her findings."
It is understandable that the researcher, Ms. Karpinski, is frustrated. It seems that the media, and others, want to be able to jump to conclusions about Fb and other SNSs. There is the sense that as an application or as a tool, it must be for time wasting and non-academic-work related activities.
Eszter Hargittai writes in a posting on Crooked Timber that
based on data about 1,060 first-year students at the University of Illinois, Chicago collected on a paper-pencil survey in Winter, 2007 (data set described in detail here), I find no relationship between whether someone uses Facebook and self-reported GPA (collected in categories, not in specific grade-point average terms). Additionally, I also have data on number of times the respondent used a social networking site the day before taking the survey and there is no correlation between that measure and grades either.
It is also worth noting that an important finding of my study was how Facebook use is not randomly distributed among participants (e.g., parental education, race, ethnicity predicted adoption) so it’s helpful to look at the relationship of various factors such as grades (or whatever else) to Facebook usage while controlling for other variables.
There are lots of reasons why one may or may not find a relationship between Facebook use and grades. I won’t get into that here, it could make for a very long essay. The point of this post is mainly to suggest a careful approach to what we see in the press and at conferences.
Searching for Bruce Sterling : Bad at Sports
Mike Rohde, Sketchnotes captured on-site and live in a Moleskine pocket sketchbook while attending SXSW Interactive, March 13-17, 2009 at the Austin Convention Center in Austin, Texas.
Searching for Bruce Sterling : Bad at Sports:
"Note too that Rohde’s notes have Sterling saying, “connectivity will be an indicator of poverty rather than an indicator of wealth,” and not connectivity = poverty."
Note on the previous post.
Let Them Eat Tweets
"Where once it was “hypnotic” and “mesmerizing” (words often used to describe Twitter) to read about a friend’s fever or a cousin’s job complaints, today the same kind of posts, and from broader and broader audiences, seem . . . threatening. Encroaching. Suffocating. Twitter may now be like a jampacked, polluted city where the ambient awareness we all have of one another’s bodies might seem picturesque to sociologists (who coined “ambient awareness” to describe this sense of physical proximity) but has become stifling to those in the middle of it."
Again the the images of the urban street, of poverty, homelessness, wandering lost in the crowd surface in the description.
As the night deepened, so deepened to me the interest of the scene; for not only did the general character of the crowd materially alter (its gentler features retiring in the gradual withdrawal of the more orderly portion of the people, and its harsher ones coming out into bolder relief, as the late hour brought forth every species of infamy from its den), but the rays of the gas-lamps, feeble at first in their struggle with the dying day, had now at length gained ascendancy, and threw over every thing a fitful and garish lustre. All was dark yet splendid—as that ebony to which has been likened the style of Tertullian.
The wild effects of the light enchained me to an examination of individual faces; and although the rapidity with which the world of light flitted before the window prevented me from casting more than a glance upon each visage, still it seemed that, in my then peculiar mental state, I could frequently read, even in that brief interval of a glance, the history of long years. (Poe, "The Man of the Crowd")
And in the last paragraph of the story, the narrator describes the man he has been following who seeks to be surrounded always by the crowd:
It was something even more intense than despair that I then observed upon the countenance of the singular being whom I had watched so pertinaciously. Yet he did not hesitate in his career, but, with a mad energy, retraced his steps at once, to the heart of the mighty London. Long and swiftly he fled, while I followed him in the wildest amazement, resolute not to abandon a scrutiny in which I now felt an interest all-absorbing. The sun arose while we proceeded, and, when we had once again reached that most thronged mart of the populous town, the street of the D—— Hotel, it presented an appearance of human bustle and activity scarcely inferior to what I had seen on the evening before. And here, long, amid the momently increasing confusion, did I persist in my pursuit of the stranger. But, as usual, he walked to and fro, and during the day did not pass from out the turmoil of that street. And, as the shades of the second evening came on, I grew wearied unto death, and, stopping fully in front of the wanderer, gazed at him steadfastly in the face. He noticed me not, but resumed his solemn walk, while I, ceasing to follow, remained absorbed in contemplation. ‘The old man,’ I said at length, ‘is the type and the genius of deep crime. He refuses to be alone. He is the man of the crowd. (Poe, "The Man of the Crowd")
Facebook and MySpace users 'fed up with spam marketing messages
"Research by the IAB also suggested that despite the rush by brands to tap into the potential of websites such as Facebook and MySpace, the reality is that users are turned off by marketing tactics.
Only 5% of those surveyed said they had signed up to a social networking profile set up or sponsored by a brand.
The report also found that 12% of those surveyed do not like the fact that other people can monitor online activity on websites such as MySpace and Facebook. The survey concluded that this suggested that users were not particularly aware of the privacy functions that can be set to limit what can be seen."
As the space of SNSs becomes increasingly populated by advertisers and spam dealers, the self-defensiveness of users will rise, as well as their resentment about intrusions into what they see as their private space, or the space of their social network.
On the other hand joining groups set up by brands is quite a lot like joining a group of people who support a cause--it is more a badge of alignment tacked on to one's profile than something that requires one to actually do something. Or am I wrong?
And, this clamour of voices from the margins of the page will make it more difficult for other useful developments to emerge. So, for example, teachers who wish to find a way to sue SNSs to reach students where they are will be just another voice in the crowd, indistinguishable from marketers. This is a worry even if teachers are offering something of value:
However, the survey, carried out by research firm Opinion Matters for the IAB, found that 28% of social networkers were happy to join a new group if it offered exclusive content.
"Despite its popularity this study shows that respect for the user is just as important in social media, users will not respond to spam or irrelevant advertising," said the IAB senior marketing manager, Amy Kean.
Does there come a point where there is just too much noise in the channel for valuable messages to get through?
15 April 2009
Twitter Demographics
"Reuters reporter Alexei Oreskovic recently authored an interesting blog post about the demographics of Twitter users. What he discovered was that 18-24 year olds, the traditional social media early adopters, are actually 12 percent less likely than average to visit Twitter (Index of 88). It is the 25-54 year old crowd that is actually driving this trend. More specifically, 45-54 year olds are 36 percent more likely than average to visit Twitter, making them the highest indexing age group, followed by 25-34 year olds, who are 30 percent more likely."
What Twitter does for people my age is clearly different from what Facebook does for the 18-24 age bracket. It is interesting that Fb is seeking to become more like Twitter in some respects doubtless to please the people in the older age brackets--not to please those who are still undergrads. Can Fb be all things to all people? Does it want to be?
Facebook usage stats
"The latest comScore data is good news for Facebook, ranking the site as the sixth most popular website in the world with 275 million unique users each month. That exceeds the 200 million user mark that Facebook recently made public, but regardless of different metrics the trends are interesting here.
Facebook now accounts for 4.1 minutes of every 100 minutes we spend online, which is a sign that we are using the site more deeply - or just getting lost because of that new design. The site accounts for more than 30% of all time spend on social networking sites, up from just over 12% a year earlier."
10 April 2009
Sheryl Sandberg on Facebook's Future - BusinessWeek
On the questions about Facebook's business strategy
It's a really simple answer, which is that our business is advertising. We're not waiting to find our business. We found it, and it's actually working very well.
Keep this in mind. Fb is not about serving the social needs of its users, it is about finding ways to use the social to sell things to its users. But, who are academics who want to use Fb to connect with students? Are they "Friends"--part of the social network? Or, are they just other advertisers, in search of capturing eyeballs, of selling something to the real clients--whose attention is or wants to be elsewhere?
04 April 2009
Me Media
"Ultimately, though, the success of sites like MySpace and Facebook may have less to do with the opportunities they provide for self-expression than with peer pressure. Once Facebook is available, many students feel compelled to join simply because everybody else is using it. “I tried to hold out and go against the flow,” Cal Nannes, a junior at Davidson College, in North Carolina, said. “But so many of my friends were members that I finally gave in.” Many Facebook users also admit that they tailor their profiles to win the approval of their peers. “I want to seem self-aware, but not a pretentious asshole,” Matt Morello, a Yale graduate who logs on to Facebook about a dozen times a day, wrote in an e-mail. He described how simply listing his favorite music became an agonizing task: “I never used to update this, thinking it was just too fraught a category (like Favorite Books still is, unless there’s some joke to make). I’m a musician: what I play and listen to has always been an important part of my identity, and it’s only fairly recently that I’ve developed the confidence to say, you know, I like this, and I don’t really care if you don’t. So what’s there now?"
A passage from John Cassidy's "Me Media", an account of the origins and development of Facebook, combined with some reflections--like this--on what it all means. Peer pressure to join, and to join one needs to create a representation of oneself.
Nicholas Carr, also writes about this anxiety of creating this online existence "avatar anxiety"
Your online self ... is entirely self-created, and because it determines your identity and social standing in an internet community, each decision you make about how you portray yourself - about which facts (or falsehoods) to reveal, which photos to upload, which people "to friend," which bands or movies or books to list as favorites, which words to put in a blog - is fraught, subtly or not, with a kind of existential danger. And you are entirely responsible for the consequences as you navigate that danger. You are, after all, your avatar's parents; there's no one else to blame. So leaving the real world to participate in an online community - or a virtual world like Second Life - doesn't relieve the anxiety of self-consciousness; it magnifies it. You become more, not less, exposed.(Nicholas Carr -- The love song of J. Alfred Prufrock's avatar)
02 April 2009
Clara Shih - The Facebook Era - About the Book
"The book asserts that Facebook messages, pokes, and wall posts represent a new form of more casual communication (just like email is more casual than a phone call) and have made it socially acceptable to have more casual, lower-commitment relationships with a greater number of people."
This I think is a very interesting assertion, and it may be true.
29 March 2009
Facebook at 5 - Is It Growing Up Too Fast? - NYTimes.com
"For their part, Facebook executives say they are less interested in being cool than in being a useful place where anyone can go to share elements of their lives.
“The people who started the company weren’t cool. I’m not cool,” Mr. Cox says. “If you look at the people who work here, it’s much more nerdy and curious than cool.
“Cool only lasts for so long, but being useful is something that applies to everyone.”"
This is how Facebook as a company sees itself--no longer as a place just to hang out but as a place where useful work is accomplished. But, accomplished via the social aspect relations of workers or groups of workers.
Internet evangelists say that when a technology diffuses into society, as Facebook appears to be doing, it has achieved “critical mass.” The sheer presence of all their friends, family and colleagues on Facebook creates potent ties between users and the site — ties that are hard to break even when people want to break them.
Many who have tried to free themselves of their daily Facebook habit and leave the site, like Kerry Docherty, a student at Pepperdine University’s law school, speak of a powerful gravitational pull and an undercurrent of peer pressure that eventually brings them back.
This "peer pressure" is perhaps the strongest force holding Facebook together, but--from one perspective--this may be the essence of "cool."
26 March 2009
BBC NEWS | Technology | Bruce Sterling - Prophet and loss
"'People don't pay attention to novels. The socially important parts of American communication are not taking part in novels. You can write them but they are not changing public discourse.
'You can also say that everybody in society has moved up a notch and everybody just wants the executive summary.'"
17 March 2009
I’m Not Actually a Geek
"Reflecting both on Schmidt’s statement, and my own use of Yammer at my company, I’m seeing that microblogging is slowly replacing a lot of my email activity.
As more companies take up microblogging with services like Yammer, Socialcast, Present.ly and SocialText Signals, employee communications amongst employees will both increase and divert away from email. Something like this:"
It seems that the element of immediacy that microblogging tools have give them an advantage over slower moving and more thought-out communications styles -- like e-mail. (And we used to complain about e-mail.)
As Hutch Carpenter continues,
Microblogging’s premise is that public proclamations of what you’re doing and information that you find are a new activity for people, and they have value. Information is shared much more easily and in-the-flow of what we’re all doing anyway. In an office setting, I continue to find the way Dave Winer describes it quite useful: narrating your work.
To what extent is all communications a status update?
Facebook's New Privacy Controls Encourage Openness - ReadWriteWeb
"As an alternative to the new 'Public Profiles' (formerly called 'Pages'), these additional settings allow you to pick and choose which parts - if any - of your private Facebook profile are available for anyone to see. According to a company blog post, this means that now people won't need to friend you in order to view the content you want to make public."
This also could be a useful feature for both teachers and students, allowing a degree of visibility and communication without crossing the border to invasion of privacy or surveillance.
Reverse Network Effect
"The Internet economy has been built on the network effect (i.e. the effect that one user of a good or service has on the value of that product for other people). Investors and entrepreneurs have treated this like Moore's Law. But just as Moore's Law hits physical constraints, network effects have a limit in many types of online communities. Indeed, in some cases, a reverse network effect may exist: as new people join, others are motivated to leave. This dramatically affects the length of the competitive advantage enjoyed by these ventures."
I wonder too how attempts to move a SNS like Fb away from its initial success by, for example, opening the network to those who want to sell you something increase the likelihood that the sense of community is lost, or that the value of social contacts diminishes. In other words, it is not just scale, but the types of characters that flock to the network...
Facebook's New Public Profiles: Good for Businesses, Bad for People - ReadWriteWeb
It is difficult to keep up with the changes in Fb, but this helps illuminate some of the ways Fb is trying to change, to accommodate larger institutional users. However, this might be worth investigating as a way for smaller institutions -- e.g. a university class -- to connect to students.
02 March 2009
The Realtime Moment
"Gillmor: We’re at the threshold of the realtime moment. The advent of a reasonably realtime message bus over public networks has changed something about the existing infrastructure in ways that are not yet important to a broad section of Internet dwellers. The numbers are adding up — 175 million Facebook users, tens of thousands of instant Twitter followers, constant texting and video chats among the teenage crowd."
15 February 2009
The Medium - Being There - The Subtle Art of the Facebook Update - NYTimes.com
"In 2007, a college student explained to me that he preferred Facebook to MySpace because MySpace (in his view) was for emo kids who liked Death Cab for Cutie and Facebook was for clever kids who liked words. “The Facebook interface is minimalist and not stupid or smeared with fingerpaint like MySpace,” he said, if I remember right. “It leaves room for wit.”"It is interesting to think that Facebook is more about the use of words--especially the clever use of words. How important is the status update in Facebook? Does it show connection to the group? Does it show engagement with the Social Network Site? Does it show a willingness to communicate with others which the other more static aspects of the profile do not?
11 February 2009
FaceTime - Employee Web 2.0 Usage in Corporate Networks Up to 10 Times More than IT Estimates
"Press Release
FaceTime Finds Employee Web 2.0 Usage in Corporate Networks Up to 10 Times More than IT Managers' Estimates
Unified Security Gateway 2.0 identifies and manages 1,400 Internet applications; new real-time data shows Web 2.0 usage penetration at 100%
BELMONT, Calif - February 3, 2009 - Actual network data from FaceTime Communications reveals that employee use of Web 2.0 applications such as Instant Messaging, IPTV, VoIP and Social Networking on corporate networks exceeds IT estimates by up to 10 times."
04 February 2009
The Adaptive City -- the adaptive place
"Yet there is possibility for more active conscious interventions too. To enable this, the informational city must be reconfigured with a series of seams, hooks, handles and portals. In the language of code, the city itself has APIs, through which information can be read and written, enabling a self-reflexivity that in turn enables the city to adapt, just as those early cities were able to through physical proximity. A panoply of varying smart meters, sensors, and schema are required to feed data to the model, and so the only possible technical architecture is an open one. This openness also provides safeguards against misuse, opportunities for creative hacking and enables a vast set of possible outputs. As openness informs the model, with more data-sources providing a richer model, the aggregate is open too, a web service that citizens can immerse themselves in just as much as city officials and planners. The model is something everyone can touch, as it is comprised of everyone. It encourages interaction, reflexivity and adaptation."
And he wonders:
Will architecture, property development and urban governance be able to deal with a system which indicates the pace the city is actually lived at, which indicates how designs are actually used and abused, which requires an ambient ongoing service design model?
How much more easily could these technologies he imagines be implemented in small places: cyber cafés, learning commons, libraries. These are places that are now immersed in technology and where the pace of unfolding technology technology use is a major challenge.
Five years of Facebook. How will it last five more? | Media | guardian.co.uk
Jemima Kiss writes in the Guardian:
"Facebook has many challenges: the battle against social networking fatigue, information overload, the migration of influential early adopters to more specialist networks like Twitter and the intensifying scrutiny of its plans to make money."
Technology is all about change, but will change come due to "networking fatigue"? Bobbie Johnson gives some details about what this might be also in the Guardian Technology Blog:
Listen. I have blog. I use Twitter. I idly flick through lists of people I'd forgotten I ever knew on Facebook. I've even got a MySpace page, although I don't like to talk about it. They are great ways of connecting people, and they're very exciting when you start using them, because they allow virtual contact in ways that are analogous to - if not the same as - real life. You know, communicate with people. That old thing.
Perhaps what we all need is a lesson in setting boundaries on social networking sites, like this one from Nick O'Neill from allfacebook.com: 10 Privacy Settings Every Facebook user should know
25 January 2009
Is the writing on the wall for penmanship? - The Boston Globe
"'My first reaction was horror,' Florey said in an interview at her home, 'then I thought, 'Why would anyone use handwriting in today's world?' I write my books on the computer. I discovered two schools of thought: One is that it wouldn't matter if nobody learned handwriting because we all have computers, and the other is that this is an interesting, historic, valuable, and beautiful skill that has been around for thousands of years, and we are just tossing it out.'"
This is Kitty Burns Florey talking about her book Script and Scribble: The Rise and Fall of Handwriting. But, the second argument—the argument for the value of handwriting—just is not that convincing. It is like arguing that electric lights have spoiled our ability to appreciate the beauty of candles or that recorded music has caused us to lose our appreciation of the concert hall. It may be quite true, but one can imagine someone saying, "Ah, yes, I wish I did have the time or the opportunity to go to a concert and be able to hear Angela Hewitt play Bach, but not living in London or New York, the CD is the best I can do—in fact, it is amazing that I can have access to this music whenever I want," &c.
The better argument is for the necessity of handwriting. But, perhaps nobody actually believes this argument anymore. I began this blog with a quotation from Orwell on this subject. In the society depicted in Nineteen Eighty-four handwriting is suppressed by the government, and Winston Smith's discovery of it is a turning point:
Actually he was not used to writing by hand. Apart from very short notes, it was usual to dictate everything into the speak-write which was of course impossible for his present purpose.
George Orwell Nineteen Eighty-four Part I
Winston Smith wants to set down his thoughts, "the interminable restless monologue that had been running inside his head, literally for years." But, confronted with the blank paper, his first reaction is an inability to write anything, and second, a stream of "rubbish" written in a rush "in sheer panic." However, the act of writing this incoherent fragment changes something in his mind.
The curious thing was that while he was doing so a totally different memory had clarified itself in his mind, to the point where he almost felt equal to writing it down.
I suspect that this is what many people besides Orwell felt about writing. Writing was an essential part of the job of thinking. And for Orwell, something that an oral medium like his imagined "speakwrite" could not duplicate. Is it the same with the computer? Perhaps. I am one of those people who write on the computer all the time, and yet remain somehow unconvinced that is as good for the process of thinking as handwriting. Typing on the computer is more convenient. It is necessary and unavoidable for my work, but it is detached from the mind in some hard-to-define way.
20 January 2009
Joho the Blog
"While teenagers primarily leverage social network sites to engage in common practices, the properties of these sites configured their practices and teens were forced to contend with the resultant dynamics. Often, in doing so, they reworked the technology for their purposes. As teenagers learned to navigate social network sites, they developed potent strategies for managing the complexities of and social awkwardness incurred by these sites. Their strategies reveal how new forms of social media are incorporated into everyday life, complicating some practices and reinforcing others. New technologies reshape public life, but teens’ engagement also reconfigures the technology itself."
from the abstract to danah boyd's thesis on Social networks.
10 January 2009
The Conversation Prism
Milky Way Transit Authority
Stuck near Sol at the moment, and need a bus ticket. But, at least with a map I know where I am. But, where to go next?
03 January 2009
Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk
"Cloud computing – where IT power is delivered over the internet as you need it, rather than drawn from a desktop computer – has gained currency in recent years. Large internet and technology companies including Google, Microsoft and Amazon are pushing forward their plans to deliver information and software over the net.
But Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and creator of the computer operating system GNU, said that cloud computing was simply a trap aimed at forcing more people to buy into locked, proprietary systems that would cost them more and more over time.
'It's stupidity. It's worse than stupidity: it's a marketing hype campaign,' he told The Guardian.
'Somebody is saying this is inevitable – and whenever you hear somebody saying that, it's very likely to be a set of businesses campaigning to make it true.'"
I read this a while ago, and it has kept coming back to my mind as I have been reading about other things like the Google deal with the publishers, and realizing that freedom of information is not really on their minds at all. I think Stallman is right, and having spent an afternoon this holiday installing Ubuntu on an old computer, I feel it is important not to give into the cloud hype.
30 November 2008
You’re Leaving a Digital Trail. What About Privacy? - NYTimes.com
People and organizations, he said, are increasingly choosing to interact with one another through digital means that record traces of those interactions. “This allows scientists to study those interactions in ways that five years ago we never would have thought we could do,” he said.
ONCE based on networked personal computers, collective intelligence systems are increasingly being created to leverage wireless networks of digital sensors and smartphones. In one application, groups of scientists and political and environmental activists are developing “participatory sensing” networks.
This type of work with this interconnected network of cell phones, computer networks, and GPS networks creates a new discipline that Dr. Pentland calls "reality mining" -- in reality an extension of data mining tapping into public data.
Issues of privacy and control of one's personal data, and big-brother type surveillance become important, issues which Steve Steinberg articulates in his .CSV blog in April 08
This emerging area doesn’t have a catchy moniker yet, but you can think of it as an amalgamation of crowd theory, human terrain mapping, and social simulation. It is the science of groups; it is a new kind of quantitative political science.
The tools and theories needed to analyze social interactions are just now reaching the level of sophistication — in accuracy, in robustness – necessary to leave the lab and enter commercial duty. We are in a period analogous to the early 1970s, when developments like the Capital Asset Pricing Model and the Black-Scholes equation transformed finance, changing it from an art to a science, and opening enormous new markets in the process. Now, new equations describing “crowd dynamics” are about to change our lives. And not always for the better. This is one of the most significant technology trends I have seen in years; it may also be one of the most pernicious. (.CSV)
28 November 2008
Search Engine | CBC Radio | Is Canada becoming a digital ghetto?
1. Last week the CRTC sided with Bell against a group of small Internet Service Providers who want to offer their customers unthrottled connections where what they download is their own business and not subject to interference.
2. In last week’s throne speech the Conservative government renewed their intention to “modernize” Canadian copyright law. Their effort to do so last session was Bill C-61, a woefully unbalanced and retrograde piece of legislation that led to the greatest citizen backlash to any proposed bill in recent memory. Yet there has been no indication from new Industry Minister Tony Clement that a much-needed public consultation will take place. The best he has offered is the possibility of a “slightly different” version of the bill.
So much for net neutrality as far as Canada is concerned...
27 November 2008
Beloit College Mindset List
Number 31 on the Mindset list for the class of 2012
These students,
have never been able to color a tree using a raw umber Crayola.
It has been that many years, and I still feel peeved that they would eliminate raw umber.
19 November 2008
70 Signs of Intelligent Life at YouTube | Open Culture
Perhaps it is because "YouTube unfortunately makes these collections difficult to find" but it is only recently that I have stumbled across some amazing content on YouTube, for example, just the other day I found some interviews with J. G. Ballard. I have also enjoyed some of the @GoogleTalks, listed on the oculture page.
12 November 2008
William Gibson Interview « Void Manufacturing
UG: In Spook Country, the net is introduced in a quite specific way; it is somehow turned inside out and projected into real space. You have invented a new art form for that purpose called locative art. For example, you describe a virtual monument on the site of River Phoenix’s death. Why did you choose to write on GPS?
WG: I wanted a way to visualise the extent to which something has changed since I started writing about information technology. When I coined the word cyberspace, cyberspace was there, and everything else was here. That has reversed itself over the course of my writing. I literally think that cyberspace is now here, and a complete lack of connectivity is now there. If we could see the wireless exchanges of digital information taking place around us, we would be living in a much busier visual landscape. Most of what we do as a society we now either primarily do digitally, in what we used to call cyberspace, or we simultaneously do digitally and in the physical world. If you are driving with a GPS system, you are simultaneously driving your car and manoeuvring your car through a digital construct. I believe that very few of us are aware of the extent to which that has already happened, and I suspect that I’m not aware of it to anywhere near the real extent to which it has happened. So in this book I was looking for a more or less imaginary emergent technology or art form that will allow me to simply bring that up. The conversation in the coffee shop on Sunset Boulevard is a little more grandstanding than I usually do. I don’t think I have had a scene in a novel before where three people sit down and basically talk about a William Gibson novel without ever really mentioning it.
I guess that is the point: "very few of us are aware of the extent to which" large sections of human activity and social life have transferred themselves to what Gibson would once have called cyberspace, and very few of us are aware of the negotiation of "digital constructs" that have merged seamlessly into our experience of the real.
08 November 2008
Web 2.0 Summit
I especially enjoyed listening to Tim O'Reilly talking to Paul Maritz (VMware, Inc.) and others about cloud computing. Maritz makes the point that we are moving away from a device centric world to an information centric world. This is something we already intuitively know actively assume in our dealings with our data and information. Maritz also points out that putting our information in the cloud (in any way, even by typing a term into a search box) is taking part in an information marketplace. We are giving away some of our privacy and some personal information about ourselves in order that we get some benefit in return (e.g. an answer to our query). On a larger scale, an organization putting its information in the cloud--into that marketplace--and allowing others to add value to it through things like mashups or user tagging can make our information more valuable--to others but also to us.
31 October 2008
3 Ways Web-Based Computing Will Change Colleges - Chronicle.com
"At first I wondered why Google needed to demonstrate its popular e-mail service. Didn’t students already know how to click send? But when I hopped on the bus at George Washington University last month, I saw that the demos highlighted all the other Web services in its Google Apps for Education e-mail package for colleges, which includes a Web-based word processor called Google Docs, a Web-based spreadsheet program, and other tools.
Those tools are the cloud computing part—the term usually refers to programs that run over the Internet rather than locally on a user’s computer. And Google officials explained that many students don’t yet know about those new Web-based services."
and then an anecdote
At a summer program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology that I sat in on last year, I asked students whether they had stayed up all night at the library finishing their final group projects, as the program’s organizers had predicted. One of the students looked at me as if I were crazy. Yes, he had worked late—until about 3 a.m.—but he had been at home by himself. The students all contributed to a shared document using Google Docs, which anyone in the group could edit online from anywhere. All of the students were essentially logged in to the same computer (in this case off at Google somewhere), one adding a paragraph at the end, another changing the font, and another rewriting the title. There was no longer any need to worry about getting everyone in the same room at the same time.
It is interesting that Google spends time promoting this service, letting students see the advantage of this type of virtual collaboration. Will this be something that all students will suddenly grasp--will there be a tipping point beyond which it will be a strategy too obvious to need explaining--or will students need to learn new strategies of collaboration and communication? And, is Google not just teaching students about this, but also gathering information on how informal groups like this collaborate?
Universities review plagiarism policies to catch Facebook cheats | Education | guardian.co.uk
"Universities are reviewing their plagiarism policies to clamp down on students who use Facebook to cheat.
Plagiarism experts have warned universities and colleges to be aware of students copying from each other when discussing coursework on social networking sites.
Gill Rowell, from the consultancy Plagiarism Advice, said universities needed to rework their plagiarism policies with 'internet working in mind' but insisted institutions were taking cheating seriously enough."
Although Facebook gets the headline--and obviously represents one form of what could be called collaborative dishonesty--the article goes on to talk about Wikipedia and Googled essays as other sources of plagiarized material.
17 October 2008
Social Media Information Flow
This may be a bit more extreme than the average person's social media information flow, but I created a diagram (using MindManager) showing how the information I create flows through the online world.
It does show the complexity consumers are dealing with in the Web 2.0 world, and it will be interesting to see how the leading services help us deal with this. Facebook is of course the best example to date.
This is the question, how do we deal with this and how much is too much to manage. See also, Josh Catone at ReadWriteWeb -- Visualizing Social Media Fatigue
16 October 2008
Ning and the Proliferation of DIY Social Networks - eMarketer
To satisfy users who seek more control over their online socializing experiences, a number of do-it-yourself (DIY) networks have emerged. The sites allow for unprecedented levels of customization for networks on nearly any topic, as well as the ability to connect to others who share the same interests and goals.
Is this the future of social networking...or just the logical conclusion that will never arrive?
09 October 2008
Scobleizer — Tech geek blogger » Blog Archive Dave Winer says I sound like a monkey «
"The Social Graph is NOT my social network.
My Social Network is my friends list.
But the Social Graph shows a LOT more than that."
Who can say if this is the right term for this concept. However, it seems like the crucial element of applications like Facebook.
Face to Facebook Learning | Learn at All Levels | Fast Company
"It was from this perspective I felt disoriented as a perspective client used Compete Inc.'s analysis of what people do on Facebook as proof (proof?) it's not a place where people learn. The manager was echoing nonsense I hear from educators and business people alike who argue social networking does not constitute learning and that a platform like Facebook is too immature to foster authentic education."
