Showing posts with label open systems. Show all posts
Showing posts with label open systems. Show all posts

31 August 2010

Slavoj Žižek: Wake up and smell the apocalypse

Slavoj Žižek: Wake up and smell the apocalypse
New Scientist
30 August 2010 by Liz Else
Do these issues arise from problems about what humans are becoming, and the relationships between the public and the private?

Yes. These are problems of the commons, the resources we collectively own or share. Nature is commons, biogenetics is genetic commons, intellectual property is commons. So how did Bill Gates become the richest man on earth? We are paying him rent. He privatised part of the "general intellect", the social network of communication - it's a new enclosure of the commons. This has given a new boost to capitalism, but in the long term it will not work. It's out of control.

Take a bottle of water: I produce it, you buy it. If I drink it, you cannot. Knowledge is exactly the opposite. If it freely circulates, it doesn't lose value; if anything, it gains value. The problem for companies is how to prevent the free circulation of knowledge. Sometimes they spend more money and time trying to prevent free copying than on developing products.


And now others are working even harder to enclose part of the social network commons.

22 November 2009

The Noble Savage Space

Cyberspace the liberator is now a tyrant’s tool | Bryan Appleyard - Times Online
Cyberspace was born free, but everywhere it is in chains. Once a promised land inhabited by visionaries, libertarians and freedom fighters, it has become a war zone. “The Harry Potter age of the internet,” says Professor Ron Deibert, “is over.”
Deibert is director of the Citizen Lab at Toronto University, which monitors state and corporate control of cyberspace. In a recent Citizen Lab survey of 69 countries, it learnt that 40 had internet restrictions.
I have been reading lately about Deibert and the Citizen lab. They are doing interesting work (citizenlab.org)

06 August 2009

Serendipity

Ping - The Digital Age Is Stamping Out Serendipity - NYTimes.com:
Is it possible to build in some randomness or chaos into an information system?
Biz Stone, a Twitter co-founder, wrote to the Twitterati, 'Repositioning the product to focus more on discovery is an important first step in presenting Twitter to a wider audience of folks around the world who are eager to start engaging with new people, ideas, opinions, events and sources of information.'

Interesting observation that the digital world hides so many things that were formerly visible, a person's music collection, choices of movies, even now, I suppose, books. Now, we reveal things about ourselves on our Facebook pages, or through the random pictures of us others might post.
But note, randomness has to be anarchic and disorderly. Serendipity, is really the wrong word. The word was coined by Horace Walpole (in 1754) according to the Wikipedia. Walpole gives an example definition:
One of the most remarkable instances of this accidental sagacity (for you must observe that no discovery of a thing you are looking for, comes under this description) was of my Lord Shaftsbury, who happening to dine at Lord Chancellor Clarendon's, found out the marriage of the Duke of York and Mrs. Hyde, by the respect with which her mother treated her at table.

"Accidental sagacity" is not how we would define the term today. Walpole's example shows what we would more likely call deduction, putting together clues to find out something that one would otherwise not have known. It shows simply a discovery, suddenly understanding something, but it is not necessarily a fortunate or happy discovery, the most important element of our current definition.
The idea of the accidental encounter contains the possibility of the happy chance discovery, but also of the unhappy or unpleasant discovery. And, in any system to do what Biz Stone wants to do, viz. engaging with new people, ideas, opinions, &c, the happy is only just a part of it.

01 July 2009

Facebook Says It Wants You to Be Less Private - But Why?

Facebook Says It Wants You to Be Less Private - But Why?:

"Facebook Director of Communications Brandee Barker told us this in response to our 'why' question:
Sharing is at the core of our product. Finding people you know, learning about people you don't know, searching for what people are saying about topics that interest you can generally only happen when people are open and choose to share. By recommending more open defaults, more people will be able to connect on the site.
Is that really true? Facebook is about learning about people you don't know and searching for what people are saying about topics that interest you? Far more often, we've heard the saying 'Facebook is about people you know, Twitter is about people you want to know and MySpace is about people you used to know.'

It is interesting that Facebook started off as a private space, controlled and limited, and that now it wants to become a more open space. Of course, it could be that Facebook wants to use this openness to sell users things, to convert the space into a market where interactions are less and less a the user's control. It is like the developments of urbanization, except in reverse. It may create some benefits as well as some irritations.

03 January 2009

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk

Cloud computing is a trap, warns GNU founder | Technology | guardian.co.uk:
"Cloud computing – where IT power is delivered over the internet as you need it, rather than drawn from a desktop computer – has gained currency in recent years. Large internet and technology companies including Google, Microsoft and Amazon are pushing forward their plans to deliver information and software over the net.
But Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and creator of the computer operating system GNU, said that cloud computing was simply a trap aimed at forcing more people to buy into locked, proprietary systems that would cost them more and more over time.
'It's stupidity. It's worse than stupidity: it's a marketing hype campaign,' he told The Guardian.
'Somebody is saying this is inevitable – and whenever you hear somebody saying that, it's very likely to be a set of businesses campaigning to make it true.'"

I read this a while ago, and it has kept coming back to my mind as I have been reading about other things like the Google deal with the publishers, and realizing that freedom of information is not really on their minds at all. I think Stallman is right, and having spent an afternoon this holiday installing Ubuntu on an old computer, I feel it is important not to give into the cloud hype.

28 November 2008

Search Engine | CBC Radio | Is Canada becoming a digital ghetto?

Search Engine | CBC Radio | Is Canada becoming a digital ghetto?:

1. Last week the CRTC sided with Bell against a group of small Internet Service Providers who want to offer their customers unthrottled connections where what they download is their own business and not subject to interference.

2. In last week’s throne speech the Conservative government renewed their intention to “modernize” Canadian copyright law. Their effort to do so last session was Bill C-61, a woefully unbalanced and retrograde piece of legislation that led to the greatest citizen backlash to any proposed bill in recent memory. Yet there has been no indication from new Industry Minister Tony Clement that a much-needed public consultation will take place. The best he has offered is the possibility of a “slightly different” version of the bill.


So much for net neutrality as far as Canada is concerned...

19 November 2008

70 Signs of Intelligent Life at YouTube | Open Culture

70 Signs of Intelligent Life at YouTube | Open Culture
Perhaps it is because "YouTube unfortunately makes these collections difficult to find" but it is only recently that I have stumbled across some amazing content on YouTube, for example, just the other day I found some interviews with J. G. Ballard. I have also enjoyed some of the @GoogleTalks, listed on the oculture page.

08 November 2008

Web 2.0 Summit

Web 2.0 Summit
I especially enjoyed listening to Tim O'Reilly talking to Paul Maritz (VMware, Inc.) and others about cloud computing. Maritz makes the point that we are moving away from a device centric world to an information centric world. This is something we already intuitively know actively assume in our dealings with our data and information. Maritz also points out that putting our information in the cloud (in any way, even by typing a term into a search box) is taking part in an information marketplace. We are giving away some of our privacy and some personal information about ourselves in order that we get some benefit in return (e.g. an answer to our query). On a larger scale, an organization putting its information in the cloud--into that marketplace--and allowing others to add value to it through things like mashups or user tagging can make our information more valuable--to others but also to us.