28 June 2009

Great Wall of Facebook: The Social Network's Plan to Dominate the Internet

Great Wall of Facebook: The Social Network's Plan to Dominate the Internet:
"More than 200 million people—about one-fifth of all Internet users—have Facebook accounts. They spend an average of 20 minutes on the site every day."

And more importantly in this article, the point that Facebook sees itself more as a rival to Google than as a rival to other SNSs:
"We never liked those guys [Google]," says one former Facebook engineer. "We all had that audacity, 'Anything Google does, we can do better.' No one talked about MySpace or the other social networks. We just talked about Google."

The ultimate direction of Facebook is as an alternative model for the web to Google and its approach to organizing the world's information. But, the real question is: is this model possible? For one thing, will the social network model scale, and especially will it remain human, community-like, or will it come to feel inhuman, monolithic, and autocratic?
In this regard, I think that readwriteweb has got it right:
These are the diminishing returns. The more the model scales, the more it will irritate users, and the more users will switch off, and the sooner growth will slow down and reverse. As with email, Facebook can "make up for this with volume." But unlike with email, which is virtually free, Facebook has to pay money to serve each user.
Sorry, "Coca-Cola wants to be your friend" is in no way an enduring revenue model. If it sounds phony, maybe that is because it is phony.
The one lesson from social media marketing is that authenticity matters. What no one has shown -- and methinks this would be impossible -- is how to scale authenticity.

15 June 2009

Studies Explore Whether the Internet Makes Students Better Writers - Chronicle.com

Studies Explore Whether the Internet Makes Students Better Writers - Chronicle.com:
"In a shorter project, undergraduates in a first-year writing class at Michigan State University were asked to keep a diary of the writing they did in any environment, whether blogging, text messaging, or gaming. For each act of writing over a two-week period, they recorded the time, genre, audience, location, and purpose of their writing.
'What was interesting to us was how small a percentage of the total writing the school writing was,' says Jeffrey T. Grabill, the study's lead author, who is director of the Writing in Digital Environments Research Center at Michigan State. In the diaries and in follow-up interviews, he says, students often described their social, out-of-class writing as more persistent and meaningful to them than their in-class work was.
'Digital technologies, computer networks, the Web — all of those things have led to an explosion in writing,' Mr. Grabill says. 'People write more now than ever. In order to interact on the Web, you have to write.'"

On the one hand students write more, but on the other, as Mark Bauerlein notes, citing "the reading and writing scores in the National Assessment of Educational Progress, which have remained fairly flat for decades. It is a paradox, he says: 'Why is it that with young people reading and writing more words than ever before in human history, we find no gains in reading and writing scores?'" I suppose one could ask, even if students are doing more are they doing enough? And, where does the feedback come from to make them try to write better?

08 June 2009

Well, so much for the paid content model

Xark!: The newspaper suicide pact:
"I think I'll remember last week as the moment when I finally knew, with a certainty approaching fatigue, that the newspaper industry – the business and passion that both shaped and warped me over the past 20 years – had chosen ritual suicide. The choice appears grimly reached and irrevocable."

Read the whole article at Xark...